Skip to main content
9-579.2

COMMENTARY

SECTION 229.56—Liability
A. 229.56(a) Measure of Damages
1. In general, a person’s recovery under this section is limited to the amount of the loss up to the amount of the substitute check that is the subject of the claim, plus interest and expenses (including costs and reasonable attorney’s fees and other expenses of representation) related to that substitute check. However, a person that is entitled to an indemnity under section 229.53 because of a breach of a substitute-check warranty also may recover under section 229.53 any losses proximately caused by the warranty breach, including interest, costs, wrongfully charged fees imposed as a result of the warranty breach, reasonable attorney’s fees, and other expenses of representation.
2. A reconverting bank also may be liable under section 229.38 for damages associated with the illegibility of indorsements applied to substitute checks if that illegibility results because the reduction of the original check image and its placement on the substitute check shifted a previously applied indorsement that, when applied, complied with appendix D. For more detailed discussion of this topic, see section 229.38 and the accompanying commentary.
9-579.3
B. 229.56(b) Timeliness of Action
1. A bank’s delay beyond the time limits prescribed or permitted by any provision of subpart D is excused if the delay is caused by certain circumstances beyond the bank’s control. This parallels the standard of UCC 4-109(b).
9-579.4
C. 229.56(c) Jurisdiction
1. The Check 21 Act confers subject-matter jurisdiction on courts of competent jurisdiction and provides a time limit for civil actions for violations of subpart D.
9-579.5
D. 229.56(d) Notice of Claims
1. This paragraph is designed to adopt the notice-of-claim provisions of UCC 4-207(d) and 4-208(e), with an added provision that a timely section 229.54 expedited-recredit claim satisfies the generally applicable notice requirement. The time limit described in this paragraph applies only to notices of warranty and indemnity claims. As provided in section 229.56(c), all actions under section 229.56 must be brought within one year of the date that the cause of action accrues.

Back to top